Maybe it’s our mothers’ training us not to act as if we think too well of ourselves. Maybe it’s creatives’ rather lowly status in ad agencies — below the account and media types. Maybe it’s lack of practice or training in making presentations. Whatever caused it, it seems to me that creatives have a hard time appearing confident, and therefore, selling their ideas.
Even the best creative concepts, when presented by someone who’s hemming and hawing, staring at their shoes, fiddling with papers or chuckling nervously, can bomb. An unconfident presenter unconsciously signals the client to reject his or her ideas. The client may think, “Hey, if even the art director/writer is that unsure about it, the idea must be bad.”
Ever heard the expression, “Fake it ’til you make it?” If you are one of us creatives who is afflicted with excessive humility, there is hope, if you can employ a few basic tactics for projecting and developing confidence.
• Make eye contact with people.
Eye contact shows you’re interested in what the other person is saying. And when you really listen, you’ll likely forget you’re nervous. Practice on friends or co-workers. Don’t glare unblinkingly at someone. They might think you’re trying to stare them down. Breaking eye contact every now and then is natural.
• Smile.
A pleasant smile projects friendliness and self-confidence. It invites another person to get to know you. It lets them know you’re safe to interact with. Knitted brows, signifying worry, set off alarm bells. You don’t want that. Practice your smile in a mirror. That way, you can train your muscles to do just the right thing when the time comes. And guess what. Smiling helps you feel more cheerful and less nervous.
• Stand tall.
Confident people generally have very good posture. Practice “thinking tall.” Imagine your head is being pulled upward by a string attached to the top of your skull. Pull your shoulders down, not back. Tuck in your derriere and tighten your abdomen slightly. Relax your hands. Stand with your feet at least a foot apart for stability. When you’re properly aligned, look at yourself, side and front, in a full-length mirror, so you remember what “right” looks and feels like. Notice how when your posture is straight and tall, your diaphragm has more room to fill, so you can breathe more deeply. Shallow breathing is what we do when we’re afraid. Deep breathing promotes calmness.
• Be prepared.
The Boy Scout motto applies to anyone who wants to project self-confidence. If you’re doing a presentation, practice it in advance, visualizing your audience in place and imagine how you might answer any questions they may ask. Have your papers, boards, and props all in order, so when you need them you won’t need to fumble. Spend a few minutes imagining yourself going through the presentation smoothly and confidently. This mental exercise will help you replicate your imagined good performance in real life.
• Look the part.
Your clothing and hair style are the first thing people see. Fairly or unfairly, they make instant judgments based on your appearance. When you’re dressed as a confident person would dress, you feel more confident. Here’s another mirror exercise: take a good hard look at yourself from head to foot. Is your hair saying things about you that aren’t very complimentary? Get advice from a good hair stylist as to the best style for you, and have it professionally cut. How about your clothes? Are they baggy, ill-fitting, worn, out of style, or just plain strange?
Look through magazines or visit department stores and see what people of your age and job description are wearing. Go thou and do likewise. If you’re presenting to buttoned-down business types, you may have to tone down the creative attire a bit. Not entirely, but you don’t want to scare them with a wild East Village or indie punk look.
• Speak clearly and at good volume.
My voice sounds just fine to me, inside my head. But people on the outside have told me that I speak very softly, which doesn’t project confidence. If you are a soft-spoken person like me, you may have to kick up the volume a little to be heard properly. This will take a little practice. You might speak into your answering machine or other recording device to get the right volume and tone. 
How do actors and opera singers manage to project their voices without microphones? By pushing the sound out with their diaphragms. To get the feel of diaphragmatic breathing, lie down on the floor and concentrate on breathing into your “tummy,” as a baby or kitten does naturally when sleeping. Fill up your tummy (diaphragm) first, then let the air fill your lungs. Then push it out from the diaphragm. Once you’ve got that down, practice diaphragmatic breathing when you’re standing up, and when you’re talking in everyday life. Amaze the supermarket checkout person with your fabulous pear-shaped tones.
• Act as if
When you meet new people, act as if you are perfectly at ease. If you’ve incorporated some of the suggestions above, you may actually be more at ease than you’ve ever been before. You’re concentrating on your posture, voice and presentation, not on your worries. Act as if you’re confident, and what do you know? Suddenly, you are.